The Camp Fire Girls; Or, The Secret of an Old Mill — Story, Setting & Ideas

(4 User reviews)   1167
Garis, Howard Roger, 1873-1962, Cluff, Warren Y. [Illustrator] Project Gutenberg 2018 Not confirmed
Camp Fire Girls -- Juvenile fiction; Mystery and detective stories; Haunted places -- Juvenile fiction Readers of public-domain and historical texts
Project Gutenberg digital edition en

Edition facts

Words 62,377
Reading time 272 min
Text sections 33

For The Camp Fire Girls; Or, The Secret of an Old Mill — Story, Setting & Ideas, the stored edition analysis reports 62,377 words, 4 hr 32 min estimated reading time, and 33 detected text sections.

The text analysis averages about 11.5 words per sentence, while the detected sections provide another way to judge how the source is divided.

Project Gutenberg metadata also associates the work with “Camp Fire Girls -- Juvenile fiction,” connecting these edition facts with the source record’s subject description.

This editorial note examines how Howard Roger Garis structures the girls' night march through the woods, using the pocket lamp as a recurring image and the descent from Bear Pond to Green Lake as a spatial anchor for the mystery.
Share
Editorial Edition Score 4.8/5

Calculated from edition completeness, EPUB availability, text structure and catalogue metadata. Not a user rating.

How this score is calculated
  • Description quality20 pts
  • Title & short description10 pts
  • Source metadata20 pts
  • Text length15 pts
  • Chapters / structure15 pts
  • EPUB file integrity20 pts

Total of 100 points, scaled to a 2.5-5.0 range. Editions with an empty description or a missing EPUB file are not scored.

Edition quality

Read the Text

ou for a memo. pad, Nat!” and once more Alice embraced her chum.

“Why so pensive?” asked Marie, as, to give entrance for her friends she opened the door of the little cottage, over which she presided as mistress. “Has anything happened, Natalie? Did you miss in Latin to-day?” and Marie, dropping her books on a chair in the hall ushered her chums into the little library. The girls were on their way home from the Academy and from class had gone to a meeting of the Camp Fire Girls Association, which had recently been started in their town. They had been initiated as “Wood Gatherers” of the Dogwood Camp Fire, which name Mrs. Pierce Bonnell, the Guardian, had chosen for the group.

“No, nothing has happened,” said Natalie slowly. “I was just thinking what delightful fun we would have this summer if we could really gather around a camp fire of our own, out in the open.”

“Well, why couldn’t we?” asked Marie. “Let’s think about it, anyhow. I’m going to ask Nellie to make tea. It’s real chilly, even if the bluebirds are here and the flowers almost out. Oh, I have it, I’m going to choose the name Bluebird—I wonder what that is in Indian?”

“Che-no-sag-ak!” exclaimed a guttural voice, as Marie opened the door of the dining room. “Che-no-sag-ak! Wah! Pale face maiden heap talk much. Ugh!”

“Oh Jack! How you startled me!” cried Marie, shrinking back, with her hands to her breast, as she beheld her brother and his two intimate chums, Phil Anderson and Blake Lathrop, calmly seated at the dining room table, luxuriously regaling themselves on water crackers and old cheese, with some ginger ale which they had evidently smuggled in from the corner grocery.

“What is it?” echoed the voice of Mabel, as she and the other two girls crowded to the portal. “Phil!” she went on, “and Blake! Have you been listening to what we were saying?” she demanded as she marched out and stood half-threateningly over her brother.

“How could we help it—the way you talked?” he inquired, defensively.

“And so Marie is going to be a bluebird; is she?” went on Jack with a grin. “Fine! That’s the Indian for it that I was reciting—‘Che-no-sag-ak!’ Little bluebird of the wildwood, come and let me have thy feathers—have thy feathers for my new hat, for my new hat made of satin. Little——”

His voice died off into a gurgle for Alice, with the intimacy of a chum of Jack’s sister, had clapped her hands over his mouth, to the destruction of a cracker he had been about to munch.

“Look out for that cheese!” warned Phil.

“And the carpet!” added Blake.

“Well, let him stop making fun!” snapped Alice, as she glided away before Jack could take a fair revenge.

“What’s it all about, anyhow?” asked Blake, when quiet had been somewhat restored. “Why all this Indian hocus-pocus? Has a medicine show come to town?”

“It’s the Camp Fire Girls,” declared Jack, trying to get up from the carpet some of the cracker crumbs before Nellie, the maid came in, for Jack and his chums were only in the dining room on sufferance. “Sis has been mooning around the house about it for the last three weeks.”

“I have not, Jack Pendleton!”

“Gibbering about Wood-gatherers, Fire-makers, and what not,” went on the irrepressible brother. “She’s been looking in the back of the dictionary for something or other—I thought she had fallen down on her Latin, and was trying to work off a condition.”

“I was looking for Indian words,” declared Marie, “only I couldn’t find any. You know we can each choose an Indian name,” she went on to her girl chums, ignoring the three boys. “It may be anything, only it ought to mean something in English. But my dictionary doesn’t have any Indian information in it.”

“I have an Indian book at home,” said Blake Lathrop quietly, speaking to all, but looking rather more intently at Natalie. “I think it has a lot of names such as ‘bluebird’ in it. If you girls want to pick out titles for yourselves I’ll bring it over.”

“Oh, will you, really?” cried Mabel. “I want an Indian name, too, if the rest are going to have them.”

“Say, what is this Camp Fire Girls’ racket, anyhow?” asked Phil. “I’ve heard you talking about it, Mabel, but I thought it was one of the Academy societies.”

“It’s nothing of the sort,” declared Alice, while Natalie went to the piano and softly played a weird Indian song, in a haunting minor key.

The Camp Fire Girls; Or, The Secret of an Old Mill opens with a challenge and a ring ceremony, but the narrative quickly pivots to movement through uncertain terrain. The girls' night march in Chapter XV exemplifies Garis's method: a single electric lamp becomes the group's lifeline, its beam "like some modern firefly" picking out a path that is alternately hard-packed and treacherous. The descent from Bear Pond to Green Lake is not merely a change of setting but a structural device—the downward slope signals a shift from isolation toward possible rescue, while the rain intensifies from drizzle to "regulation downpour." Garis uses the girls' physical progress to mirror their psychological state: each step is both a practical necessity and a small act of defiance against the unknown.

The Pocket Lamp as a Guiding Motif

Throughout the night march, the Guardian's "little pocket lamp" is more than a convenience; it is the organizing principle of the scene. Garis describes it as a "brilliant pencil of fire" that "streamed out of the lens" to reveal the trail. The lamp is mentioned at intervals—flashed ahead, used to avoid wandering off the path—and its limited range creates a tight focal point. The girls move from darkness into small pools of light, a rhythm that heightens tension. When Mabel observes that they have been going downhill, the lamp confirms her reasoning: the terrain changes under its beam. This recurring image ties the physical journey to the act of discovery, suggesting that knowledge, like light, is partial and must be advanced step by step.

Descent as Narrative Structure

Garis builds the chapter around a clear spatial logic: the girls are moving from higher ground (Bear Pond) to lower (Green Lake). Mabel articulates this: "If you'll notice we've been going down hill for the last ten minutes." The descent is not merely geographical—it organizes the plot. Each downward step promises proximity to cottages, help, and the familiar camp. Yet the path is not straightforward; there are "little glades" that require dips and rises. This uneven descent mirrors the story's own movement between hope and setback. The girls' khaki suits, described as shedding rain "like a duck's back," offer a practical counterpoint to the emotional weight of being lost. Garis uses the physical details of the journey—the slope, the wetness, the lamp—to create a structure that feels both purposeful and precarious.

Dialogue as a Map of Uncertainty

The girls' exchanges during the march reveal their reliance on each other's observations. Marie's exclamation "Oh, if we ever get to our dear, old camp again!" is met not with reassurance but with a practical question from Alice: "When we get a little nearer what?" Mabel's reply—"Green Lake"—grounds the conversation in geography. Mrs. Bonnell, the Guardian, contributes by noting the descent and by clutching Mabel's arm after a stumble. The dialogue does not advance the mystery directly; instead, it maps the group's collective reasoning. Each speaker adds a piece: direction, distance, memory of the lake. Garis uses this back-and-forth to show how the girls pool their knowledge, turning individual observations into a shared navigational tool. The talk is urgent but not panicked, reflecting the Camp Fire ethos of resourcefulness.

The Rain as a Shifting Atmosphere

Garis calibrates the rain's intensity to match the scene's emotional arc. The chapter begins with a "drizzle" that soon becomes a "regulation downpour with all the accompaniments of wind and chilling atmosphere." The change is not abrupt but gradual, mirroring the girls' growing fatigue. Yet the rain also serves a practical function: it justifies the repeated mention of the khaki suits' water-shedding property, a detail that keeps the focus on survival rather than despair. The wetness is never merely atmospheric; it is a problem to be managed. When Marie says "I'm not at all damp—except outside," the joke underscores the group's determination. The rain, like the darkness, is a constant pressure that the girls must navigate, and Garis uses it to maintain a steady undercurrent of discomfort without letting the mood become hopeless.

Readers following the girls' night march will notice how Garis uses small, repeated details—the lamp, the descent, the rain—to build a coherent spatial and emotional journey. The mystery of the old mill is not yet in view, but the structure of this chapter establishes a pattern: progress is measured in steps, light is limited, and the group's cohesion is tested. Pay attention to how later scenes echo this movement between known and unknown terrain.

The pocket lamp bobbing through those woods brought back my own dusk walks, flashlight beams cutting thin paths between maples. That same careful, patient suspense lived in Boy Scouts in California; or, The Flag on the Cliff — Story, Setting & Ideas, where a cliff edge held its secret like the old mill held its mystery. Each book made me feel the dark pressing close, then parting for a small circle of light.

Scarlett Davis
1 month ago

Carter Roberts
2 weeks ago

Victoria Hill
2 weeks ago

Grayson King
3 weeks ago

4
4 out of 5 (4 User reviews )

Add a Review

Your Rating *
  • ...
    Sara Valdez - 1 month ago
    This is a pleasant, old-fashioned story about a group of girls who uncover a secret. The characters are likeable, and the mystery is engaging enough. However, the plot moves slowly at times, and some parts feel a bit too convenient. Still, it's a nice, easy read for younger audiences and nostalgic adults.

  • ...
    Jean Sanford - 1 month ago
    The story feels dated and lacks the excitement of modern adventure tales. The 'secret' is predictable, and the characters are too perfect to be believable. The writing is heavy on description but short on action, making it a chore to get through. I was disappointed by the lack of depth in both plot and character development.

  • ...
    Amy Rogers - 2 weeks ago
    Such a charming and wholesome story! The Camp Fire Girls are wonderful role models—brave, clever, and loyal. The mystery of the old mill keeps you guessing, but the real heart of the book is the friendship and growth of the girls. It's a delightful read that captures the spirit of adventure and young camaraderie.


Reader reflection

Record your reading impressions

A brief reflection can help important ideas stay with you longer.

Your progress 0 / 10
1

Where are you in your reading?

2

How much did you enjoy the reading experience?

3

How likely are you to recommend this book?

4

What was the reading difficulty like?

Related eBooks